They were a lot more snuggly when they were puppies
It's hard to keep warm in a Japanese house. We usually try to pick a single room and do everything in that one room, with the doors closed all over the house in a short of attempt at airlocks to keep the warm air in and the cold air out.
You can't tell, but in three minutes she is going to jump up and insist that she will ACTUALLY DIE unless I let her into the hallway, which she will sniff once before deciding to come back to bed.
All through summer the dogs happily sleep throughout the day in whatever comfy spot they choose. As soon as it gets colder, they develop the urge to roam, getting up what seems like every ten minutes and asking to be let in and out of room for seemingly no purpose other than to ruin my life. They particularly like going out to the garden and then waiting exactly the time it take for me to get back under the kotatsu before wanting to come inside again.They scratch at the door and whine as though they will die of cold if I don't open the door immediately. I jump up (again), open the door and then... they just sit and stare at me while all my warmth gets sucked out into the garden and the wind blows into the house.
I hate clothes on animals, but her first winter Kuri's undercoat didn't grow in and she couldn't stay warm, so we had to put this coat on her. I promise it was necessary!
A while ago I "liked" a facebook page that posted lots of cute puppy pictures. Who doesn't like puppy pictures, right? They also post dog related news, which depressingly often means stories about animal cruelty and the always inadequate sentences the perpetrators receive. Another depressingly frequent topic is "loyal dog waits X period of time for humans who won't return." Sometimes the humans in the story are dead, but mostly they have abandoned the dog. Here are some examples:
What is it that attracts people to these stories? A mix of pathos, admiration for the "loyal" dog, a longing for some unconditional love? They even appear as entertainment in movies from Australia's Red Dog
to America's (version of Japan's) Hachiko.
I hate these stories. With a passion. I don't see heartwarming tales of doggie goodness, I see human ugliness and little else. Take perhaps the most famous "loyal dog waits" tale of them all, Hachiko, for example. The House of Two Bows does an amazing job of eviscerating the mythology around the story:
To me, the drooping ear is an emblem of the years of hardship
that Hachiko suffered on the streets. He did not turn his back on any
happy home to keep the flame alive for his dead master. The fact is that
there was no other home for him to go to. All parties involved were more interested in maintaining the myth of the downtrodden wanderer who had nothing else
other than the memory of his master; his impoverishment only heightened
the tragic poignancy of the story, and that’s why it had to be
maintained. The pedagogical value of Hachiko’s story did not have to be
steered towards imperialistically-tinged notions of unerring devotion
towards a singular, grand master. It could have been a lesson in
humane charity, in animal welfare, in collective social responsibilities
towards homeless pets, or really, any needy living creature. But the
fact that any alternative interpretations were drowned out by the
dominant ideology of loyalty and national unity in a time of heightened
militarism is represented by that single, falsely pricked ear.
Dogs were evolved to pay attention to us... They are this extraordinary example of a species that we have bred on the basis of how much attention they pay us; how closely they look us in the eye and hang on our every word. I mean, it's the most narcissistic thing we have ever done as human beings. A dog pays more attention to your face than a human being does.
And that's the thing. We made dogs to love us, to be devoted to us, to DEPEND on us. And we let them down, often and catastrophically.
This post contains Amazon affiliate links. That
means if you click and then buy the item I get a small commission. It
does not mean that I am being paid to promote a particular product or
opinion. I will only include affiliate links that are directly related
to the subject of a post. If you want to know why I have begun including
affiliate links you can read about it here.
I'm joining Authentic Parenting and Hobo Mama for Sunday Surf. Share your best reading of the week, and link up your post at either blog!
For more great reading, visit Hobo Mama or Authentic Parenting for the latest Sunday Surf and linky. Happy Surfing!
Kids give so much negative feedback, so much of the time (I won't / I didn't / I can't / I don't want to) that it's positively thrilling, at
times, to know that there might be a tiny adult somewhere, inside my
phone, who is going to say something encouraging to me, send me a nice
email, do something that will make me laugh or maybe just give me ten
seconds of respite so I don't yell. I need encouragement through my day,
and often the place I get the most is through my phone. I don't think
this is anything to be sneezed at.
And yet I've read and heard a few people saying some pretty judgy things
about mothers who spend too much time on their phones, and it bothers
me. I don't disagree that probably, lots of us could do a better job to
get the balance right between boredom, engagement and distraction (I
talked about pushing kids through the boredom barrier recently, and I'm
all too aware that sometimes I use my phone as a way to avoid pushing
through my own). However, this attitude always, always makes me
uncomfortable, and not (just) because it makes me feel guilty.
I don't know. I think that most mothers who I see idly thumbing on their
phones are probably bored; bored and tired and wondering how much
longer they have to stay at the swings until they can legitimately claim
it's time for dinner. And if you think they shouldn't be bored and
tired, if you would prefer to see them engaging their children more
actively, I have a solution - offer to babysit and give that mother a
bit of time to herself. Yes, that's right - walk up to her and say 'hey
there, mama, you look like you could do with a break. How about I push
that swing for you while you take an hour or so to read a book in that
coffee shop?'
Is this too weird? Is it impossible? Would nobody ever, ever, do it,
because they would seem like some kind of crazy kidnapper, offering to
look after a stranger's children? Well, maybe this is right, but my
opinion is: if we don't know a person well enough to offer to babysit
her kids, we don't know her well enough to judge the fact that she is
on her cellphon
http://www.theguardian.com/science/video/2013/sep/26/science-teaching-japan-video Really interesting video about attempts to promote science in Japanese schools. I was particularly interested by one teacher's observations that kids don't like science because they just want to get the answer, they aren't interested in the process. They are used to, and expect, instant gratification.
In literary fiction, like Dostoyevsky, “there is no single,
overarching authorial voice,” he said. “Each character presents a
different version of reality, and they aren’t necessarily reliable. You
have to participate as a reader in this dialectic, which is really
something you have to do in real life.”
Dr. Castano added that, in many cases, “popular fiction seems to be more focused on the plot.”
“Characters can be interchangeable and usually more stereotypical in the way they are described,” he said.
With limited resources and the hospital
an hour away, the family did not know what to do. They loved their
granddaughter and wanted to find her help so they approached the
leaders in their community about the situation. The leaders contacted
some missionaries in town and told them about this family.
And just like that, this little girl
was brought to an orphanage, where she would be separated from her
family for the next 3 years.
The family wasn't offered
transportation to the hospital, or advice on nutrition for a
malnourished child, or high caloric foods or help paying hospital
bills. The only option presented was the removal of their child.
So for the next three years a child
with a family that loved her sat in an orphanage. She became one of
many children cared for by multiple caregivers a day that came and
went and picked up their paychecks at the end of the month. She got three nutritious meals a day
and toys donated from America to play with and the occasional trip to
town for ice cream, but she lacked a child's greatest need- a family
to love her. She watched adoptive parents arrive to
take their kids home and was left wondering where her family was and
why she wasn't with them.
Essentially, an orphan had been
created.
While this little girl wondered, an
hour away a family in a village was left missing their daughter.
We—collectively, as a society—are teaching our kids the very thing that
so many of us spend an entire adult lifetime trying to unlearn.
Sweets = happiness. Sugar = fun. Cupcakes = love.
The celebration hasn’t happened until we feel sick and our teeth are coated in sugar residue.
Our bodies naturally crave sweet things because of their easy energy
content. Encouraging a psychological attachment to sweets as a shortcut
to positive feelings is unwise. And yet, we reinforce this message
constantly to our very young children with a flashing neon sign that
says JUNK FOOD = FUN PARTY.
I can’t help but believe that in doing so we will pass on all of our
negative patterns. When I’m sad, frustrated, depressed about the winter,
cold, tired, or overwhelmed, I want SOMETHING CHOCOLATE WITH FROSTING.
It’s a test of my will power not to eat crap when I feel strong negative
emotions, searching for a certain level of happiness and satisfaction
in sweets. I usually win, but it’s hard and I know I’m not alone. I see
this kind of complaint posted everywhere.
We were taught that whether we want to admit it our not. That’s a lesson
we learned at the knee of this idyllic childhood-party-sweets-holiday
mentality. If we don’t want to raise kids who struggle with the food
issues of our generation we need to stop the constant association of
positive social events and sugar.
I’ve written before that I grew up in the south, in an area intensely
battling racism and homophobia. The area is odd. At the “yamboree” as we
called the county fair, the Ku Klux Klan had a booth each year, and
also sometimes the Ku Klux Klan would parade down town and give out
candy to all the kids.
When I was five I was put in a different school because there was an
ESL (English as a Second Language) program there. You may be wondering,
“what’s wrong with that?” Well, for starters, I was born in Ohio and
English was my native tongue. I was reading novels by kindergarten
(totally spelled that wrong the first time, fail) and I prided myself on
the fact that I had an extensive vocabulary for a toddler. I had been
speaking English with exquisite finesse up to that point in my life
(okay, that may all be a bit of an exaggeration, but you get the point).
So I didn’t know why I was being put in an ESL program, but I didn’t
argue because who’s going to listen to a five year old? At that age, you
don’t question things, you just accept. I carried forth with my days
throwing raisins at the teacher and drawing cartoon characters on the
desks. It wasn’t until later in life I tried to analyze the situation
and came to this conclusion: I was put in that program for one reason, I
was a shy Asian girl and everyone jumped to the conclusion that I couldn’t speak English. I know I tend to joke about this story, but there’s a lesson to be learned.
As a young child, I didn’t understand race or skin color. I assumed
everyone was white, including me. I hope I can speak for most
Asian-Americans here, but there is that earth-shatterning [sic] moment in our
childhood when we realize we’re not white.
It isn’t a scarcity of whales that is bringing down the curtain, or even the
complicated politics of whaling. It is something far more prosaic and
inexorable: Norwegian children, even those who grow up in the seafaring
stronghold of Lofoten, simply do not want to become whalers any more. Nor do
they want to brave storm-tossed winter seas to net fortunes in cod, as their
forebears have done for centuries. Instead, they aspire to safer, salaried
jobs in distant cities or with the offshore oil industry, and they have been
leaving their island communities in droves.
What a legacy Japan could achieve if it
not only celebrates the things that make Japan distinct and unique but
openly looks to share that with the world and in the process widen the
definition of what it is to be Japanese to include the best of other
cultures too. Because some of those other cultures are already here,
they are already making significant contributions to Japanese life. They
raise families, they participate in the local community and they
contribute in myriad untold ways to the growth of the nation.
In 2020 Japan will seek to introduce itself to the world.
Hopefully it’ll be an honest introduction.
And unlike Britain the rest of the World will be welcome for more than just the summer.
It seems to me that a lot of the worst homophobia stems from looking at a
gay person and seeing the “disgusting” sex they have, rather than
seeing a person, a person with passions and interests and likes and dislikes and dreams and, well, a life.
So much of the discussion of “the homosexual lifestyle” centers on this
idea that gay people spend their lives obsessed with going from bar to
bar for sex rather than, well, having a range of interests and forming a
range of relationships.
Animals, Linguistics (The first link should explain why those are together today!)
...according to recent studies, animals really do have regional accents.
Yes, that’s right. Dogs generally tend to have a different pitch, tone,
and display a variety of vocal mechanisms depending on where they are
from. The Canine Behavioiur Centre in Cumbria explained that Scottish
dogs bark somewhat more lightly than dogs in Liverpool, for example. It
gives me unspeakable pleasure to envision a dog speaking with a brogue.
Cows were also found to have regional dialects by John Well,
professor of phonetics at the University of London. This is interesting,
as in English they tend to be capable of producing one consonant. In
Mongolia and parts of India they are capable of producing complex
plosives by bursting forth with a gutteral umboo in Mongolian and hambaa in Bengali.
Unfortunately, this theory does not hold water across the animal kingdom. Cats make a sound very similar to meow around the world. In France they go miao, in China they go mao, in Sweden they go mjau, and in Turkish mijyav. Could this be attributed to cats’ universal not-giving-a-fuckage? Probable.
Naoto Matsumura and his elder parents lived on a rice farm in Tomioka, a
coastal town in Fukushima prefecture, known for having one of the
longest cherry blossom tunnels in Japan.
After hearing the hydrogen explosions at the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear
plant, eight miles away from their home, the Matsumuras attempted to
evacuate. However, they were turned away from a relative in Iwaki, a
coastal town in southern Fukushima prefecture. She feared they had been
radioactively contaminated. Afterwards, they were turned away from a
shelter because it was full.
So they returned to their home, where his parents stayed until his
mother became ill in April 2011. She then moved to her daughter's home
in Shizuoka where there was no room for the Matsumura's animals.
Therefore, Naoto Matsumura decided to stay—to take care of them.
He told
filmmakers Jeffrey Jousan and Ivan Kovac that he gradually took on the
task of caring for cattle, pigs, cats, dogs, and an ostrich (the sole
survivor of a flock of 30 birds) throughout Tomioka, all left behind by
owners who were initially told the evacuation would be temporary and
short-term:
Our dogs
didn’t get fed for the first few days. When I did eventually feed them,
the neighbors’ dogs started going crazy. I went over to check on them
and found that they were all still tied up.
Everyone in town left thinking they would be back home in a week or
so, I guess. From then on, I fed all the cats and dogs every day. They
couldn’t stand the wait, so they’d all gather around barking up a storm
as soon as they heard my truck. Everywhere I went there was always
barking. Like, ‘we’re thirsty’ or, ‘we don’t have any food.’ So I just
kept making the rounds.
Over a thousand cattle and hundreds of thousands of caged chickens died
from starvation in Tomioka. Then on May 12, 2011, the Kan administration
ordered the euthanasia of surviving cattle. But a bright spot for
animal survivors was that Japanese authorities have allowed Matsumura to
remain to care for animals since the return of the town's other 15,000
residents is unlikely.
You do not necessarily punish a dog by ignoring it.
If a dog wants you to go away, ignoring them is a carrot. Even the
happiest married couples probably realize it’s nice to see your spouse
leave so you can have a bubble bath. Love you – go away – come back
later. Do not assume your presence is always a gift to the universe.
You’re special, but not THAT special. None of us is.
The point being that in order to aspire to compassionate – to be more
humane and kinder, we need to stop talking so much and we need to start
listening.
We listen by watching the dog’s reaction. When you reach to pat a
dog on the head and see that slight ducking and shying away, then take
note. Look for escape and avoidance behaviours. They can be hard to
spot. Relief can look oddly similar to joy.
Avoid a technique-centric approach and choose communication. When
you stop – really stop – and listen, you realize that all dogs respond
to positive reinforcement. Unfortunately, too often, the human thinks
they are being positive and the dog firmly disagrees. You must truly
hear what the dog is saying.
Tens of thousands of minors live in children’s homes in Japan, but
cultural and legal issues keep most of these youngsters needing caring
homes from being united with couples who want a child to love.
A Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare survey shows that 29,399
children were living in orphanages in 2012. But while more than 7,000
couples applied to adopt or become foster parents every year between
2006 and 2010, only 309 children were adopted in fiscal 2010, according
to ministry figures.
This week’s “Document ’02″ (Nippon TV, Sunday, 12:55 a.m.) will profile
the Sakamotos, a Tokyo couple who are raising five foster children,
ranging in age from 5 to 9. In the entire city of Tokyo, there are only
200 registered foster families. According to specialists, most orphans
grow up severely traumatized, which is why family-type foster care is so
important. But almost all of these orphans are forced to spend their
entire childhood and adolescence locked up in institutions.
Research shows growing up in an institution
often leads to disadvantages in emotional development as well as
education and employment, which is why many say attitudes towards
adoption need to be changed in Japan.
"I
used to have a very negative image of adoption and I think a lot of
other people do too," explained 38-year-old housewife Tomoyo Suzuki,
adding that her thinking changed after she went to a seminar about it.
She and her husband went on to adopt two babies now aged three and one.
"I think a lot of people are concerned about blood ties."
Prime
Minister Shinzo Abe -- who criticized the "baby hatch" for encouraging
parents to opt out of their responsibilities -- and his wife, Akie,
themselves rejected the idea of adopting.
It’s still difficult. To imagine what it’s like without a real home.
One of the volunteers is literally in tears as we pull away, bidding
farewell to the staff and thanking them for the opportunity to visit.
We can escape. We can return to our apartments, Skype our parents, and
continue on with our lives. They will wake up, go to school, and return
to a place not unlike school, where they will most likely live for the
next few years, until reaching 18 or 20.
We saw one day. One atypical day. They live it for years. It’s not
horrible, it’s not cruel, but it can’t be what’s best; even a mother
shouting and screaming for ten minutes because you forgot to call home
is a sign of love. Something that just can’t just duplicated without a
home, a family.
I volunteer at an orphanage in Japan. When people
hear about my volunteer job, they often ask me a lot questions. A lot of people
are curious about Japanese orphanages since it’s something that is hardly ever discussed
openly. I decided to write answers to the most common questions I’m asked about
Japanese orphanages.
I wrote a masters' thesis a while back. It was about Lolita subculture, as in the fashion not the perversion. In that thesis I compared the English language media and popular press depictions of Lolitas as spoiled teens who are rejecting adulthood, sex-phobic and infantile with ethnographic research that shows a very different reality. I described a lot of the articles newspapers and magazine published on the topic as being from the "what's new in wacky Japan" school of journalism. You know what I mean; inaccurately reporting that a fringe body modification is a trend sweeping the nationor reporting that an artwork is an actual fashion. Everyone just knows Japan is weird, so editors don't fact-check, and once something has gone to print in the NYT everyone else just assumes it's a valid story and jumps on the bandwagon.
Is it strange that so many unmarried Japanese people aren’t in
relationships or interested in being in one? Not really. A Pew survey
this year, concerned mainly with online dating, began by asking
Americans who are not married or living with a partner whether they are
in a “committed romantic relationship.” Seventy-one percent said no. Seventy-five percent of those who are not in a romantic relationship said they are currently not looking for one, numbers that are much higher than in Japan. About half of single Americans
said they haven’t been on a date in the last three months. The number
of Americans in their late teens and early 20s who have never had sex is also rising: about 29 percent of women and 27 percent of men, according to the National Survey of Family Growth. (That survey of Japanese people under 30 refers to “dating,” not sex.)
Nearly 40 percent of American women have never been married, according to one survey, and nearly 20 percent of American women in their 40s have not had children, according to another. Both those numbers are steadily rising.
The “were not interested in or despised sexual contact" number does
seem very high, though the “or” seems to be doing a lot of work in that
sentence. A 2008 survey
of found that 10 percent of American women between 18 and 44 reported
“low sexual desire.” And plenty of people living in any culture who do
experience sexual desire don’t actively look to fulfill it with another
person for various reasons.
Yes, I’m cherry-picking numbers to make a point here, but so are these Japan articles. For instance, the Guardian doesn’t note that the Japanese National Institute of Population and Social Security Research study it cites also finds that almost 90
percent of unmarried Japanese people intend to marry and that “the
proportion of singles who are consciously trying to delay marriage is
waning.”
The BBC article is condescending about them, dismissing them with: “It
seems they no longer have the ambition of the post-war alpha males who
made Japan such an economic powerhouse and no interest in joining a
company and becoming a salary man.” Well good god, I wonder why not.
Look at the economy. Look at the lack of job security. Look at the
suicide rate. Look at the global “happiness” polls. No offense to the
hard-working salaryman who enjoys his job, but it’s about time for there
to be a societal backlash against the kind of life that is expected for
men in Japan. Suited up and out the door by 5:30 AM. Breakfast is a
plastic package of white bread from a convenience store and a small can
of coffee. An hour-long commute in a packed train, standing the entire
time. A 9 to 5 office job that doesn’t end at 5 but continues until the
boss decides to leave the office, which means usually working 9 to 9
without overtime. Obligatory drinking with co-workers after work.
Usually a lot of social pressure to visit prostitutes after the drinks.
Back home late at night, reeking of alcohol and cigarette smoke. Your
children are already asleep. Your wife makes you sleep in another room.
Set your alarm for 5:00 AM and start the whole thing again the next day.
A lot of modern Japanese men see the lives their fathers led as bleak
and depressing.
This recent Vice video on sex in Japan made some interesting points about commercialisation and compartmentalisation of relationships, but mostly it just made my skin crawl. The disdainful, entitled superiority of
the guy in the video as he pays for services that he says disgust him
while belittling the women who provide them really pissed me off. So did
the 1950s overtones of his meeting with the yakuza, where he "gains
their trust" by participating in their primitive customs (tattooing and
drinking turtle blood). He then asks for the weirdest thing they have to
offer, and is *shock horror* pretty grossed out by it. As if you can't
find kinky "specialist" services anywhere else in the world.
Now, if you want to talk about marriage or birthrates (and no, they aren't the same thing) there is a really interesting story to explore.
A more typical case is probably my former student Masahiro, who’s an
executive at a famous beverage manufacturer. He works from 9 a.m. until
to midnight, six days a week, with a 15-minute lunch break at his
desk. He has Sunday off, which is when he studies English.
“I have it easy,” he said, “since I work at an international company. Japanese places are a lot worse.”
“Do you ever see your wife?” I asked.
“I see her on Sunday,” he said.
“But Sunday’s when you come here to study English,” I pointed out.
“Ah, good point,” he said.
For most people, it comes down to two choices: work like mad as a
single person and have a tiny apartment full of dirty clothes and
half-eaten Cup Ramen containers, or get married. That way, the man goes
off to work, and when he comes home after midnight, his dinner is
sitting on the table covered in Saran Wrap, and there’s hot water in the
tub. His wife and daughter are already asleep. Shopping, ironing,
cleaning, paying the bills, everything’s taken care of for him. All he
has to do is bring home a paycheck. The woman gets to do all the fun,
fulfilling things like taking care of baby, grocery shopping, cleaning,
and cooking meals. Sometimes I’ll ask my adult students how often they
see their spouses, or ask the kids when they see their fathers. The
answer is roughly on par with how often I’ve seen the Easter Bunny. I
am, however, a big fan of marshmallow Peeps, so maybe it’s not as
infrequent as you think.
Even if we were just going to talk about birthrates though, you get shoddy misreporting of very basic information. For example, just about every article that discusses Japan's birthrate written since 2011 has claimed that "sales of adult diapers exceed those for babies". While this may be true, the only evidence I have seen cited to support it is the 2011 report by ONE manufacturer, Unicharm, that is had sold more incontinence products than infant diapers. Maybe Unicharm just makes really uncomfortable or overpriced diapers.
So is this just a symptom of the demise of quality journalism generally? I don't think so. I think it's specific to the "weird Japan" preconception, and the infantilisation that goes along with it. The fantasy of the Japanese woman is inherently infantilising (see not only my post but more tellingly the comments on an aspect of this fantasy here), but Japanese men don't fare much better in the international media. If the world were a high school, Japanese men would be the geeks. The world seems to view them as sexually perverted wimps with weird hobbies, glasses and bad teeth. Can we move on from the stereotypes, please? And some fact-checking would be nice too, while we're at it.
On October 29th he skips all three meals. On October 28th he writes
死んじゃえば楽になるのに。[It would be easier if I died]
[...]早く死んじゃえばいいのに。[It would be better to die quickly]
October 27th shows his bleeding arm and a cut-throat razor in a bowl of thick blood.
I wrote before about my experiences with JHS students and self harm. It isn't surprising to see a blog in which extreme dieting and cutting are intermingled; many eating disorders are at heart self-harming. It's still upsetting. It's also an important reminder that men are affected just as negatively.
The story reminded me of the Japanese picture book 半日村 about a town with the same problem (but a different solution). The village in the story is shaded by a high mountain, much like Rjukan, and only gets a few hours of sunlight a day. Consequently few crops grow and the village is plagued by listlessness. The adults believe they were simply born unlucky and accept their fate. One day a boy, Ippei, starts climbing the mountain and digging. He carries the dirt back down to the village and throws it into the lake (the source of perpetual cold winds). Everyone laughs at him but soon other kids begin to join in. The adults scold them, saying what they are doing is useless and goes against common sense. Things have always been the way they are, and there's no use struggling against them. You can probably guess the ending, especially since I included an image that is a big spoiler ;)
Crayon Shin-chan is one of Tiger's regularly watched shows, meaning I watch it too. I quite enjoy it actually, particularly the way his poor mother Misae (who coincidentally is my age and from Kyushu) tries to cope with her son's antics (I suspect Tiger and I are laughing at different things in those scenes...).
Last week's episode was all about Misae's attempts to diet using meal replacement shakes and wearing a 5 kilo apron while doing housework.* By the end of the episode her eyes are sunken dark hollows, her checks are inverted and she barely has the energy to pick up her baby. In the comedic climax she succumbs to her hunger and her husband and kids walk in on her chugging a beer and frying some meat.
A couple of days after we watched this episode, Tiger commented to me ダイエットしないと。。。Which is a typically open-ended Japanese statement lacking a subject, but basically in context is "you'd better diet" or more literally "if you don't diet...". So, I asked him "What? If I don't diet, what?" (ダイエットしないと何?). "Oh," he replied, "I don't know. Just, you should diet." Again, I asked why. "Well, you're fat." "OK," I said, "but why is that a problem?" "I don't know", he shrugged, and went back to playing with the dogs.
I found the exchange really interesting. First, he doesn't link weight to health or even to attractiveness. You're fat, so you should diet. That's the extent of it. Perhaps, in fact, what he has internalised from the sum of the media he has consumed is in fact just "you're a woman, you should diet". In its most basic form, it isn't even an imperative "should", it's just how things are. Tiger is interested in what is normal, a fascination that is both common for all kids his age and especially interesting for him because so many of his circumstances are less than "normal". What he understands to be normal comes predominantly from television. He sees mothers on TV dieting, and thinks that is what mothers do, so he asks me to do it. He has lived his whole life in an institutional bubble, and TV has been his primary (sole?) source of information about the world outside.
It's really challenging me trying to be respectful of his ideas and cultural background while also wanting to introduce him to my values and beliefs, all with limited language ability. I mean that in both the good sense of challenge as making me think harder and deeper, and also in the euphemistic sense of "difficult". At the stage where we are now, the most I do is question him about why he thinks the things he does. I draw the line at TV shows that depict cruelty to animals and ask him to change the channel, and although I cook meat at home for him I won't buy him MacDonalds and we have had a good few conversations about why that is. That's about as far as we go. Complex issues of public health and body image can wait, but I do appreciate the chance to see what he thinks and where the influences come from. Coincidentally, as I was writing this post I clicked over to facebook and read this fantastic article:
Is obesity a serious issue? Yes. But obesity is just one symptom of
the real issue which is unhealthy living. By focusing solely on obesity,
we are turning a "lifestyle" issue into a "fat" one and are completely
missing out on giving people the information they need to be truly
healthy.
The dangerous part about this is that instead of encouraging people
to get healthy we are demanding that they get skinny and the truth is,
skinny is not always synonymous with healthy.
I wrote a lot more on the same topic including thoughts on the considerable weight gain I've experienced in Japan when I wrote about annual health checks. At school the female teachers often transfered half their lunch to a male coworker's plate. In the classroom, I heard teachers say to kids "there's some extra left over, any boys want seconds?" and others say "if any girls want to eat less, please reduce your servings now before you start eating". I wouldn't say that these were common things to hear and I ate with a lot of different classes, but hearing them at all was disturbing. Miss Fatty was disturbing. This post isn't about health or weight so much as it is about the way I see kids (and mine in particular) distilling these issues into the simple message they take away: Woman=diet.
*Funny how these representations of motherhood are never brought up in the articles circulating the media explaining how the birth rate is low because of video games and lack of sex drive. It must be the video games, I mean, what isn't attractive about being an unappreciated overworked SAHM obsessed with losing baby weight?!
Yes, that is a Battlestar Galactic uniform and yes, the seams aren't pressed. I only finished sewing it the morning of the wedding >.<
We've been married for five years today, but we've been living together for nine years and friends for seventeen, so it seems a little pointless to fixate on numbers. We spent our anniversary last year driving to another prefecture to get a psychological evaluation as part of our adoption application. We're spending this one begging someone (anyone!) to baby-sit so we can have some time off. Life moves faster than one thinks.
We rarely say "I love you". I like that. The words become overused and lose meaning~ "Can you buy milk Iloveyou?" I get that to some people constant repartition is comforting, but it isn't for me. I want it to mean something, to be said only when dripping with emotion and significance. When you know what your relationship means, you don't need everything to be said.
My husband bought new shampoo recently and I commented that I liked the smell.
"That's why I bought it," he said, "it reminded me of how your hair smelled when we lived on Churchill Avenue." We lived in that house in 2004. The shampoo I loved at the time went off the market that year and hasn't been seen since. He remembered the scent, although he never used it. Who needs "I love you"?
We were ruthless in cutting all mention of love from our wedding vows. I don't make promises I can't keep, and you can't promise to feel an emotion. I promise honesty, kindness, respect, and that I will be here 'til death do us part. If someone promised to love me forever, I'd back slowly from the room without making sudden movements. You can't make promises about how you'll feel, and if you think you can you are either delusional or lying.* I'll take the random email in the middle of a rough week that says "by the way, you are a great mum", the Sunday morning pancakes and the shampoo.
I'm not entirely without romance. At our wedding we had Dylan Thomas' "And Death Shall Have No Dominion" as a reading, and Toccata and Fugue in d minor on an antique organ played by a friend in return for a bottle of whiskey. That's pretty romantic for two one-time goths, right?
This is a random youtube video, not from our actual wedding...
And death shall have no dominion.
Dead man naked they shall be one
With the man in the wind and the west moon;
When their bones are picked clean and the clean bones gone,
They shall have stars at elbow and foot;
Though they go mad they shall be sane,
Though they sink through the sea they shall rise again;
Though lovers be lost love shall not;
And death shall have no dominion.
And death shall have no dominion.
Under the windings of the sea
They lying long shall not die windily;
Twisting on racks when sinews give way,
Strapped to a wheel, yet they shall not break;
Faith in their hands shall snap in two,
And the unicorn evils run them through;
Split all ends up they shan't crack;
And death shall have no dominion.
And death shall have no dominion.
No more may gulls cry at their ears
Or waves break loud on the seashores;
Where blew a flower may a flower no more
Lift its head to the blows of the rain;
Though they be mad and dead as nails,
Heads of the characters hammer through daisies;
Break in the sun till the sun breaks down,
And death shall have no dominion.
Dylan Thomas
*After writing this I realised that it sounds pretty offensive to people not limited to but including Whitney Houston. I'm just talking about my own preferences and feelings guys, I promise I am not judging you for yours. Honestly :)
This lovely little waterfall is about 5 km from our house
This past summer was my sixth in Japan, and it was (is) by far the driest and longest (and typooniest). In five and a half weeks it will be winter; yesterday was so hot that I wore a tank top and took the dogs to the river for a swim (they swam, I paddled~ it's not that deep!). This autumn has been hotter than midsummer in Tasmania.
Local river
The trees have been deeply confused. Friends who live further north have shared pictures on facebook of cherry trees blossoming. In our neighbourhood the leaves remain stubbornly green, despite the calendar. The neighbourhood association has done the only thing viable given the circumstances: seasonal-corrective treatment. AKA, plastic autumnal foliage affixed with wire.
#onlyinjapan
PS Yo, Brittney! Brittney Dalton! I've been wanted to get in touch but can't find you. Drop me a line :)
I’m a firm believer that children should be taught the correct names for all of their body parts. Teaching weird euphemisms like “Tinkerbelle” or “winkie” is not only detrimental to healthy sexual development but it’s downright creepy. Seriously. To quote a random website (http://www.kidscenter.org/prevention/tips-and-suggestions):
“Teach children anatomically correct names for their body parts. Research shows that when children are taught the anatomically correct names for their body parts, it enhances the pride they feel about their bodies. Just as you teach your children that a nose is a nose, they need to know what to call their genitals. Encouraging kids to use a correct and “universally” recognized word assists in other adults recognizing statements that could be abusive or worrisome. Additionally, providing correct language helps a kid understand their bodies and lets them know it’s okay to talk about and ask questions about all of their body parts.”
I grew up in a Christian, homeschooling family with an overworked mother and four siblings. This combination of factors resulted, by casual neglect rather than parental intention I should add, in my learning nothing about human bodies (including my own). I was in university and had been sexual active for several years when I first learned of the existence of the urethra. I’d never thought about it, but if you had asked me I suppose I would have said that women peed from their vaginas. I invite you to take a moment to think about how appalling that is. Needless to say, my menarche was more than a little traumatic. So, with my adult freedom from religious baggage, I planned matter-of-fact and open discussions about the body and sexuality with my children.
But.
Thinking about wieners
My dogs don’t generally bite other people. One recent exception was a friend who is very tall and slim-limbed but with a little bit of a beer belly. This confused Hayate, who while sitting beside the-afore mentioned friend on the couch, once took a curious nibble of said friend’s tummy. Fortunately the friend was more surprised than hurt, but it did make me nervous about Tiger’s penis. Soon after moving in with us Tiger exhibited enthusiasm for running through the house naked. His crotch is exactly at face height for Hayate. I was concerned that Hayate might be curious about this bounding appendage he hadn’t seen before and take a nibble, so I tried to explain this to Tiger. “Hayate will bite me?” He asked looking scared. “No no, not bite you exactly, he’ll just… You know Hayate loves wieners, right? He might mistake your penis for a wiener and take a bite, thinking it’s food. He won’t BITE you bite you.” And from that day on, Tiger has been in love with the idea that his penis is a wiener and refuses to call it by any other name.
Every two weeks I get the class schedule. I know what he is studying every period of every day.
So this whole blogging thing? Yeah, not going to be
happening in any proper way for a while. Sorry to anyone who has commented or
emailed me lately, I will get back to you but I can’t promise when.
I’m hopping on today just to talk about how much I love
Tiger’s school. I loved elementary schools here when I was teaching in them,
but seriously, seeing them from the “other side of the desk” has just made me
love them even more. They have done everything that could humanly be done to
support us, from loaning us supplies they thought would be too expensive to buy
to extra academic support through to sending walking buddies to our house every
morning to pick Tiger up so he can walk to school with friends. When I need to
buy something and the teacher thinks I won’t know what it is, she prints
pictures off the internet for me. When Tiger didn’t want to go to school one
day the teacher called to talk to him and if he still hadn’t wanted to go she
was ready to come over to our house in the middle of a class to talk to him in
person. When he did get to school, the teacher gave him a huge hug.
The teacher sends me a note every day in this book, and I respond. If anything happens at home or at school, we both know what is going on. It also tells me what his homework is and what he needs to pack the following day.
Over and above all of that, within a week of him enrolling in
the school the board of education sent two staff over to visit him in class and
talk with me, his teacher and the principal and vice principal. Because it was
me, they sent two English speakers (both were my bosses at one time or another)
so that I could speak more comfortably in English and they translated for the
school staff. They asked detailed questions about our relationship, even how
Tiger was getting on with the dogs, and we were able to come to some shared
understandings about how to tackle some of his issues in a unified way with the
greater insight that arose from the meeting. I have never felt that
anyone was not on his side, not even for a moment. The school even said to drop
around any time, just to say hi, because when kids see parents involved at
school they feel like their parents care about their education and don’t just
send them to school to get them out of the house. For a child with abandonment
issues this is even more important, of course, and I am thrilled that the
school sees me as a partner and not as a nuisance. They give me so much information about his day, it really helps me to prepare him (he likes routine and predictability, not so big on surprises). They even mentioned right away that later this year there is a family history project and they are already preparing an alternative plan for Tiger.
Excuse the fuzzy photo... his school lunch menu for the month, complete with calorie count, protein content in grams, and list of nutritionally significant ingredients.
From the first day, everyone has been supporting us. My old
boss even helped us apply for child welfare payments. The principal and the child
guidance center have been in touch to coordinate Tiger’s care in and out of
school. My husband’s supervisor sent him home with a bag full of boys’ shoes
when I called in frustration during a week of rain that the orphanage had only given
Tiger one pair and they were sodden and we couldn’t leave the house to buy new
ones because he was refusing to out the wet ones on. As ALTs we sometimes
question whether we are really part of the community; that question has been
resoundingly answered for our family and we are humbled by the kindness we have
received these past two months.
When I read great blog posts I usually share them on facebook, but this is a nice way to share them all together with a bit more room for commentary. Not all of these posts are from this week by the way; I have been so busy that I am pretty far behind with my reading.
I'm joining Authentic Parenting and Hobo Mama for Sunday Surf. Share your best reading of the week, and link up your post at either blog!
For more great reading, visit Hobo Mama or Authentic Parenting for the latest Sunday Surf and linky. Happy Surfing!
Wise Words (Tim Minchin's Occasional Address at UWA)
Don't seek happiness. Happiness is like an orgasm. If you think about it too much it goes away. Keep busy and aim to make someone else happy and you might find you get some as a side effect.We didn't evolve to be constantly content.
http://www.findingmagnolia.com/2013/09/some-thoughts-on-adoption-preparation.html
We had some discussion about whether or not we would have a biological child before adopting. From a health point of view, it would be better for my body to have a pregnancy before I'm thirty. On the other hand, I am so so glad we didn't. We could not give Tiger what he needs with other children in the picture, especially younger children.
I am not here to judge those who have faced very hard choices, because I
know what it feels like to try to get your child to sleep for two and a
half hours, while she screamed and cried and raged, every night for
I-don't-even-remember-how-long, and I know that none of the pre-adoption
training mentioned that possibility. I know what it feels like to be
unable to do anything else for an entire day because the one thing my
child needed was to be strapped on my back and taken for a very long
walk outside, or else she would scream her lungs out. I honestly cannot
imagine what it would have been like to manage that if she had not been
an only child at first, and had I not been able to be home with her. I
know I speak from a position of privilege. But I think that privilege
was something that Zinashi needed and benefitted from, and there was no
way to know before we brought her home with us if she would need more
intense help or not. We need to be preparing families for the
possibility that their child, regardless of age at the time of adoption,
might end up having some very big needs.
http://www.fineandfairblog.com/2013/09/dear-judgey-mcjudgerson.html
I share this humble as a now-reformed Judey McJudgerson. All parents I have glared at in disgust in the past: I apologise. Sincerely. And also that snarky article I once published in a local magazine about people pushing their older kids in strollers because they were too impatient to wait for the kids to walk at their own pace? Yeah, sorry about that too.
Dear Lady Judging Me At The Playground,
You seem to be reading a lot into the very tiny slice of my life that
you see. You see me vacantly tapping on my phone, and are apparently
filled with sadness for my children, whose lives you assume are slipping
away without me noticing. (I wonder what your own kids are doing that
you're missing while you sit in judgment of me?) You see my daughter
twirling in the sunlight. You see my son smiling and cooing. You see me
not noticing.
Would it be okay if I filled you in on some things you didn't see?
You didn't see this morning, when I greeted my waking daughter with a
smile and a kiss. You didn't see when I painstakingly helped her pour
her cereal and milk, then help her wipe up the spills. You didn't see me
cut up her fruit. You didn't see me dance like a ballerina while doing
so. You didn't see me smiling and baby talking to my son while I changed
the nastiest diaper you could imagine. You didn't see me grit my teeth
when he bit my breast, testing out the new teeth on the way, then sing a
silly song about how we don't bite Mama.
You didn't see me do all that before I'd had even a drop of coffee.
http://www.nohandsbutours.com/2013/09/05/dealing-with-grief/
I want to write more about this when I can. I was prepared for some feelings of loss... the loss of the lifestyle we had been enjoying and loss of some of the ideals and plans I had about family life that would necessarily be unattainable when we decided to adopt an older child. I was not prepared for what has been the biggest source of grief though, and that is the loss of the dream of the kind of parent I would be. Put simply, I guess, I thought I'd be better at it. It's hard to accept "doing the best I can" when what I want to be doing is "the very best that can be done".
But one thing that doesn’t get talked about very often is how an
adoptive parent should respond when they find themselves grieving.
Because…no matter how happy the adoptive parents may be or how much they
love their new addition…when a new child enters the family oftentimes a
part of their old life is “lost” for the adoptive family as well.
Suddenly the home that made sense and ran like a well-oiled machine is
thrown into chaos and confusion by things like a grieving child,
orphanage behaviors, attachment struggles, processing disorders, medical
needs, night terrors, or other children in the home regressing due to
the addition of a new sibling. If an older child joins the family, then
things like language barriers and cultural differences come into play.
It can feel like the magic trick where a magician quickly pulls the
tablecloth away…only you’re left wondering how and when the pieces will
fall into place again.
As a feminist, I should make clear that I believe in the true definition
of feminism … “the doctrine advocating social, political, and all other
rights of women equal to those of men.” But this assumes that men have
rights.
In the case of Baby Veronica, her father did not have the rights that
her birth mother did. He was misled. Birth fathers should have equal
rights and protections, especially in the welfare of their children.
If a birth mother decides she cannot parent her child, and the birth
father wants to raise his child, he should be given the opportunity to
do so. No other adult should be given that right unless both birth
parents have relinquished it.
Dusten Brown has proven that he loves his daughter. He has provided for
her, cared for her, cuddled her and nurtured her for almost two years.
Baby Veronica knows he loves her, and she wants to stay with him. Her
right in all this is paramount. She deserves the love of her birth
father, the man she will never forget.
Lets [sic] look at incentives Stern (and others) may have for wanting to avoid confronting the realities of the procedure.
Like most circumcised men, Stern probably does not want it to be true
that his circumcision means that he is missing out sexually. Or that as
he ages, he will likely notice diminishing sensitivity in his glans. Or
that profit incentives played a role
in the push to remove his erogenous tissue; or that other people
altered his sexuality in a permanent way when he was still too young to
do anything about it.
But the facts are what they are.
Over 50% of penile nerve endings are removed during a circumcision,
including one-hundred percent of the Meissner’s Corpuscles, the unique
fine touch nerve receptors found only in fingertips and on the ridged
band of the penis.
Mucous membrane exposed to the air for decades does callus.
Many physicians earn sizable compensation for performing circumcisions.
And it is true that your circumcision means that someone surgically
altered your body in a permanent way without first having obtained your
consent.
Wouldn’t it be nice to be able to believe that all of these
sacrifices were not in vain, that they bought you some greater good? It
would, but we can’t just believe things because they are appealing. We
can’t in good conscience marinate in denial when that means asking
future generations to pay the price by allowing a harmful practice to
continue to play out on their flesh.
According to a recent story in the Japan Times the city’s Board of Ed has recalled a junior high school
textbook due to its “descriptions of the mass lynching of Koreans following the
1923 Great Kanto Earthquake.” During
the aftermath of that massive temblor, fear mixed with old hatreds to create a
tornado of violence that swept up Yokohama’s small ethnic Korean community in a
path of death and destruction. In his book,Yokohama
Burning, Joshua Hammer writes that army commanders “whipped up rumors about Korean well
poisonings.” The lies added more fuel to the fire as vigilantes roamed the
streets, hunting for human prey.
To get to the bottom of why, we need to define what makes someone
happy or unhappy in the first place. It comes down to a simple formula:
It's pretty straightforward -- when the reality of someone's life is
better than they had expected, they're happy. When reality turns out to
be worse than the expectations, they're unhappy.
And
Paul Harvey, a University of New Hampshire professor and GYPSY expert, has researched this,
finding that Gen Y has "unrealistic expectations and a strong
resistance toward accepting negative feedback," and "an inflated view of
oneself." He says that "a great source of frustration for people with a
strong sense of entitlement is unmet expectations. They often feel
entitled to a level of respect and rewards that aren't in line with
their actual ability and effort levels, and so they might not get the
level of respect and rewards they are expecting."
For those hiring members of Gen Y, Harvey suggests asking the
interview question, "Do you feel you are generally superior to your
coworkers/classmates/etc., and if so, why?" He says that "if the
candidate answers yes to the first part but struggles with the 'why,'
there may be an entitlement issue. This is because entitlement
perceptions are often based on an unfounded sense of superiority and
deservingness. They've been led to believe, perhaps through overzealous
self-esteem building exercises in their youth, that they are somehow
special but often lack any real justification for this belief."
There's a lot I like about this article, but there's a lot it glosses over too. After-all, every generation this century has bemoaned the terrible failings of the next. It isn't a new story. The following blog post gives a very nice reply:
I graduated in 2008. Remember 2008? Oh, right. The housing market
collapsed. Global stock markets plummeted. The Great Recession happened.
I had $25,000 of student loan debt and a liberal arts degree in English
and Theatre.
In other words: Oh, Hey, Real World. I’m Katherine. I’m HERE! What’s that, you say? We’re all kinda fucked? Oh. Okay. Neat.
And, furthermore
I exist in a world in which I don’t understand what a 401K is all about.
Social Security will not likely exist by the time I will need it.
I will never have a pension.
I’ve never even filed for unemployment. Because as a freelancer, I’m never in one place long enough to qualify.
This is not unique to my job description.
This is unique to my generation.
I live in a world in which the teachers in the city of Philadelphia
are on strike because their budget issues are so rampantly unresolved
that they are returning to work without contracts, paper, or desks. I
live in a world where we’re slashing budgets so that the kids of the
next generation won’t know a childhood with art or music classes.
I’m a woman in a generation fighting insane battles for reproductive
rights that we didn’t even know until recently that we needed to be
fighting, because we had simply assumed that we had already won them.
I live in a world in which we have a black president and yet we say
hateful racist shit on Twitter when an Indian-American woman takes the
Miss America crown. I live in a world in which we give a fuck about
Miley Cyrus.
I live in a world in which we perpetuate the unpaid intern system.
I live in a world in which, since 1979, the average American worker
has seen a 75% increase in productivity, and yet wages remain flat.
I live in a world where the top 1% of earners have seen their income quadruple since that exact same year.
I live in a world that simply seems too crazy for me to handle some
days. I live in a world that sometimes makes me simply want to hide
under the covers and not come out until it’s fixed.
And here’s what’s super fucked up:
I live in a world in which I still believe there is hope for the future.
This is the rather unpleasant skeleton in the closet that the police
would rather keep hidden. A bygone era of intensive, frequent protest in
which mistakes were made on both sides. Scapegoats and quick fixes were
found, and then people were quick to move on. Injustices and false
convictions happen in every justice system in the world. However, the
Japanese state has a lot to lose and will only backtrack and grant
retrials through firmly gritted teeth. It took mild-mannered bus driver Toshikazu Sugaya
over seventeen years to win his freedom in the Ashikaga murder case of
1990. Years of campaigning to get DNA evidence re-examined were only
begrudgingly acknowledged, since the prosecutors knew that then the
truth might come out — that Sugaya’s “confession” had been bullied out
of him. He had been an easy target: divorced and a bit of a loner. Hours
of interrogation and physical abuse, and the police had their
confession. It was not until 2010 that the flawed DNA evidence was
accepted as proof of innocence, in spite of the fact that Sugaya’s
stories of his apparent multiple crimes — made, he said, in order to
assuage the duress from the police — did not concur with the witness
accounts, and that he had failed to identify the sites where other
purported murder victims’ bodies had been found.
Although there have been some vocal scandals recently and a few very
belated victories such as the Sugaya case, the situation remains
essentially unchanged. For one, Hosei University, long a site for
radical student activism in Japan, has recently been suffering under the
fist of the police, who would arrive and pick out the activists they
had already pre-planned to arrest. Campaigners say that over 100 have
been unlawfully arrested in the last few years.
In the country of the blind, the one-eyed man is king. In the country
of no crime, the police and judiciary rule supreme. Heaven help you if
you get arrested.
Travel and Adventure
We all have friends we live vicariously through, right? I am currently living out an eighteen-year-old-me fantasy through the travels of an ex-JET friend. You can read the background to his current adventures at http://joshwalden.blogspot.jp/2013/07/introduction-to-gepaq.html
We set out with torn out pages from a Rand-McNally map of the USA
(pre-smart phone days!), tents and sleeping bags on our bicycles, as
well as big packs of Clif bars and 2-3 changes of clothes. Around an
hour before sunset each night, we'd start eying homes for nice yards.
We'd knock on their doors and ask if we could set up a tent, that we'd
be out in the morning. Every night after setting up our tents we'd sip
on some homemade whisky from a mason jar we'd received in Kentucky and
plan the next day.
Five years later I want to have that feeling again.
Milan Kundera has this amazing book called "The Unbearable Lightness of
Being." The main gist is that we feel free and light in certain points
in our lives .. free from the gravity of our decisions... but this lightness is unbearable. We have a need for something heavy,
something dark to anchor us to the world. That is why lightness is
unbearable.
A: Oh, that's cool. (Awkward pause,
look around the room, shuffles feet) Uh,what are you going to do with
that?
I am pretty sure that dialogue is
repeated approximately every 18 seconds on every American campus.
It's trite. Anyhow, three years out of college I found an
appropriate response to this commonplace: “I am going to travel the
world, learn a ton of languages, drink my weight in local beers and
eat amazing food, meet beautiful people and make lifelong friends.
Et toi?”
Plans for after college. Makin' ya proud mom!
I've had a few friends and relatives
ask me about how I am doing it, how I am financing the trip, other
practical details. I was working on a farm in Poland and talking
with my friend Craig from England (Hi Craig!) as we cleaned the goat
stalls. He said a lot of his friends back home had this real wonder
about how he was able to travel, have these experiences. He gets the
vibe from them that it is this unattainable opportunity, this secret
skill that he has.
The Australian School
Your friends will be called Cheryl and Angela. You will drive badly
because you are on the wrong side of the road. You will need a big
enough back seat for the esky and the keg of beer. When you drop your
child off at school you'll hear someone yell out "Hey, bloody sit still
while I tie your shoelaces back up will ya?" There is no embassy, you
will create your own informal embassy in the tuck shop which now has a
bar. It's highly possible a few bottles of champagne will make their way
to the PTA coffee morning and the participants will need to catch the
bus home with the kids at the end of the day. The school is littered
with pictures of Opera Houses, Kangaroos and Aboriginal art. All
fundraising will involve a keg of beer and a sausage sizzle.
The central force behind all profitability is supply and demand, and child exploitation isn’t an exception.
Nobody would buy an “I Heart Nepal” T-shirt knowingly produced by an
exploited child, and likewise, neither should we buy the “product” of
begging children.
This sounds, and feels, inhuman. We want to do the right
thing, we want to help the orphanages. We feel good when we fundraise
from friends and family, when we connect with children and use our
wealth to improve their lives. We want to soothe our conscience by putting money into the hand of a begging child.
This feeling of doing the right thing, however, through the force of a
dark human ingenuity, is precisely the illusion that child begging
rings are selling.
When we hand 500 rupees to a child with a sick baby in her arms,
these guys profit, and then reinvest. They recruit more kids, and earn
more profit.
And Now For Something Completely Different
Love My Neighbor Totoro and Death Metal, but unsure how to enjoy both at once? This age old dilemma has finally been solved!